If I Built a House Again: What I’d Do, What I’d Skip, and What I’d Never Pay For
There’s one feature in my last house that I used every single day. And there’s a room that can cost $100,000, maybe a little more, that I would never build.
I’ve spent more than 30 years in construction. I’ve built my own custom homes, and I’ve helped a lot of families build theirs. So if I were building again today, here’s what I would do differently, what I’d do again, and what I’d skip entirely.
In this post:
- What I’d do differently: design for the lot, and slow down
- What I’d do again: drainage, storage, comfort, and a few upgrades I never regretted
- What I’d skip: the theater room, trend features, and upgrades that didn’t pay back

What I’d Do Differently
1. Get the Design Right for the Lot
On our first custom home, the lot was calling for a two-story house. We built more of a bungalow instead. The bigger footprint used up too much of the backyard, and we didn’t make good use of the lot. The layout was awkward too.
We had doubts. But we were being rushed, and we trusted a designer who didn’t really understand what we needed and wasn’t really listening to us. When we went to sell, the feedback confirmed what we had already suspected: the layout wasn’t right for the lot.
So today, the first thing I’d focus on is the design. Not the countertops. Not the cabinet colors. I’d look at:
- What kind of house actually fits the lot
- Where the sun comes from
- How much yard will be left
- How my family will actually move through the house
I’d care more about getting the room sizes right than about making the house bigger. (I go deeper on this in why smart design matters more than square footage.)
I’d also walk the lot at different times of the day. Pay attention to where the morning and afternoon sun lands, where the neighbors can see in, and where the driveway and outdoor spaces make the most sense. Those choices affect how a house feels long after the excitement of picking finishes has passed. If you’re working through a plan right now, this guide on how to design a floor plan that actually works in real life is a good place to start.
And if I felt pushed to approve something before I was ready, I’d stop. The schedule matters, but I’m the one who has to live there.
The schedule matters, but I’m the one who has to live there.
Scott Grozelle

2. Slow Down and Watch the Work
On the first build, life was moving fast and we didn’t pay attention to the details. I had been in the industry long enough to know better, so that one’s on me.
The second time, we followed the work closely, made time for proper inspections, and looked at things before they got covered up. I’d do that again every time. I wouldn’t assume everything was fine just because the finished surfaces looked good.
That doesn’t mean hovering over every trade or trying to manage the job yourself. It means knowing the key stages, asking when work will be covered, and getting the right professional to look when it’s appropriate. A short conversation before insulation or drywall is far more useful than finding a concern after the walls are closed.
If you want to know exactly what to look for, use my framing walkthrough checklist and my pre-drywall inspection checklist. And if you’ve never been on a job site before, here’s how to walk a job site like a pro.
What I’d Do Again
A Floor Plan That Works Hard, and Drainage Planned From Day One
For our second home, we went two-story and created a walkout on a lot that wasn’t naturally a walkout lot. We used retaining walls to make that work. That meant drainage had to be planned from day one.
We installed two drains to carry water to the storm system. Where we lived at the time, torrential rain was a real problem. Without those drains, the back of the house could have filled up like a swimming pool. We also addressed a higher water table concern at the same time, and the best time to deal with that was during the foundation.
When a site design creates places for water to collect, drainage can’t be an afterthought. I’d want the builder, the designer and the site team to think through where the water goes during a heavy storm, not just on a sunny day. That includes the grading around the home, the retaining walls, and the route to the storm system. The goal is to give water an intentional path that keeps it moving away from the house.
A Big Garage, Real Storage, and Enough Bathrooms
I’d build a big garage again, with room for bikes, tools, and everything a family collects. I’d add lockers by the garage man door again, too.
I’d also make sure there were enough bathrooms and enough square footage for the people in the house. In 30 years, I rarely saw anyone regret that. My recommendation is a master ensuite with a shower, toilet and two sinks, if the plan allows for it. Those are upgrades well worth putting money into.
I’d think about storage the same practical way: where coats, shoes, sports gear and cleaning supplies actually land when people come in. A little planning near the entrances keeps everyday items from spreading across the kitchen and living room. It doesn’t have to mean adding square footage. Sometimes it just means giving the things a family already owns a sensible place to go.

Comfort You Feel Every Day
I’d spend on heating and ventilation before finishes. We had an HRV, and the house felt fresher than anywhere else we’d lived. We had two cats and a dog, and you would never know it. In a climate where the windows stay closed for months, a properly designed and maintained HRV or ERV can make a real difference.
I’d also put in-floor heat in the basement again. That’s something we never regretted.
Fresh air and comfort aren’t things you see. They’re things you feel every morning.
Of course, those systems need to be selected for the home, installed correctly, balanced and maintained. A label on a piece of equipment doesn’t guarantee comfort by itself. The whole setup matters: the design, the installation, and whether the homeowner understands what needs to be cleaned or serviced.
The Feature I Used Every Single Day
Here’s the feature I promised you: a steam shower. I’d heard people say they couldn’t live without one, so we tried it. I used it every single day, and it’s one of the things I’ve never regretted.
But it’s only worth it if it’s done right. The waterproofing and the surrounding materials have to be designed and installed properly.
Solid Core Doors and Good Finish Work
This one costs a little, but not much: solid core doors and good finishing work. You see and touch them every day, and to me there’s nothing that feels better than a well-built door. Ours were heavy enough that we needed bearing hinges just to carry the weight. With an excellent finish carpenter and custom built-ins, the house felt complete.
Durable Materials Where They Solve a Problem
For our back deck, we used a vinyl decking membrane over a plywood substrate. Our previous home had pressure-treated decking, which meant splinters and yearly maintenance. With the new product, we could shovel the snow right off.
It solved another problem, too. The space underneath the deck was finished with soffit and pot lights, so we paid close attention to water management and the flashing where the deck met the house. I don’t regret that upgrade at all.
We also added a water softener and filtration system. Our water was pretty good, but it got better, and it was easier on the appliances. I’d still look at the actual water quality and the household’s needs before choosing equipment like this. More treatment isn’t automatically better, and these systems need upkeep.
For more on which upgrades tend to earn their keep, read new construction upgrades that are actually worth it.
What I’d Skip
The Theater Room
This one is more feedback from past clients than personal experience. Theater rooms were popular for a while in some of the homes we were building, but the demand faded. Families found them dark and cut off from the rest of the house. They ended up watching TV in the family room by the kitchen, or in a bonus room, and the theater room became something they regretted.
A theater room can cost $50,000 to $100,000. If you don’t use it, that money hasn’t improved your life. If you love movies and you’ll really use one, fine. Just don’t build it because it’s trendy.
Before I dedicated a whole room to one use, I’d ask how often the family would actually use it and whether the space could do more than one job. Could it work as a playroom, a workout area, a quiet sitting room, or a place to watch a movie with everyone nearby? A flexible room usually serves a household more often, especially as the family’s routines change.

Trend Features
Pot fillers over the stove are a good example. Some people loved them for a while, but they faded, and they were prone to issues inside the wall.
So I’d ask one question about every feature: Will we use this every day, or am I just reacting to what’s popular right now?
That question alone can save you a lot of money. I’ve watched it go the other way. Here’s how one couple’s budget exploded by $75,000 at the design center.
Will we use this every day, or am I just reacting to what’s popular right now?
Scott Grozelle
Upgrades That Didn’t Pay Back for Us
We considered triple-pane windows and even had a mock-up done. Then we had to decide how to use that part of the budget: fewer triple-pane windows, or more and larger windows throughout the house. With the southern exposure on our lot, we chose more and larger windows. We went with good double-pane, argon-filled windows with solar protection. They worked well for what we needed and for how long we planned to live there, and we loved the natural light.
Same idea with spray foam. I’d use it where it matters, like the bonus room and the rim joist, not throughout the whole house. We also added batt insulation in interior walls where sound transfer would be a concern. That didn’t cost much, but what a difference it made.
Triple-pane windows and spray foam aren’t wrong. They just have to make sense for your house and your plans. I’d compare the upfront cost with the benefit I expect while I own the house. Energy prices, the local climate, how the home is built and how long I plan to stay all matter. I wouldn’t choose an upgrade based on a slogan or a sales pitch. I’d ask: what problem is this going to solve in my house?
If you’re trying to keep a build on budget, these 5 decisions that can save you thousands are worth a read.
Overbuilding for the Neighborhood
Another mistake people make is overbuilding for the neighborhood. There were some very expensive homes in ours, but we stayed in the upper-middle range that fit our budget and the street.
I’d also pick a neighborhood that’s nearly finished. At our previous house, the dust and the nearby construction got everywhere, and it was really annoying.
The Pattern After 30 Years
If I were to build again today, I’d:
- Start with a really good lot plan and design
- Plan the drainage early
- Spend on comfort I feel every day
- Only pay for features I’d actually use
- Slow down enough to get the big decisions right
After 30 years, that’s the pattern I saw. Trends came and went, but people kept valuing a home that fit their life. Our first home taught us some very expensive lessons. Our second home benefited from them.
Trends came and went, but people kept valuing a home that fit their life.
Scott Grozelle
For more of the mistakes I see most often, read 15 mistakes people make when building a new home.
Want Help Making These Decisions?
If you’re planning a new home, a major renovation, or any renovation at all, my book Secrets Home Builders Don’t Want You to Know walks you through the process and the choices you’ll face, so you can ask the right questions before they become expensive ones.
If I built a house again: FAQ
What would I do differently if I built a house again?
Get the design right for the lot first. Then slow down and watch the work at key stages like framing and pre-drywall, instead of assuming everything is fine because the finished surfaces look good.
Which home upgrades are actually worth the money?
In my experience: drainage planned from day one, a big garage and real storage, enough bathrooms, good heating and ventilation, and solid core doors with good finish work.
Is a home theater room worth it?
Usually not. A theater room can cost $50,000 to $100,000, and many families I built for stopped using theirs. A flexible room that can do more than one job usually serves a family better.
Are triple-pane windows worth it?
They can be, but it depends on your house, your climate and how long you’ll stay. We chose more and larger double-pane, argon-filled windows instead, because of the southern exposure on our lot.
How do you avoid overbuilding for the neighborhood?
Stay in the price range that fits your budget and the street. Expensive features in a mid-range neighborhood rarely pay back when you sell.

available on amazon
Secrets Home Builders Don’t Want You to Know
A Homeowner’s Guide to Building Smart, Avoiding Pitfalls, and Staying in Control
Building a home is the largest investment most families will ever make.
Most go into it blind. Secrets Home Builders Don’t Want You to Know gives homeowners the insider knowledge builders already have — so you can avoid costly mistakes, protect your budget, and stay in control from day one.
Written by construction industry veteran turned homeowner advocate Scott Grozelle, this book pulls back the curtain on:
- Budget traps that quietly inflate costs
- Red flags most homeowners miss
- Contract language that benefits builders (not you)
- Design decisions that create lifelong regret
- How to manage your build without losing your sanity
If you’re building, renovating, or even thinking about it — this book may save you tens of thousands of dollars.
Don’t build blind. Build informed.
And I’d love to hear from you: what matters most to you in a home? The layout, the storage, the air quality, or one feature you’d use every day? Tell me in the comments on the video.
More from the blog:
- Why cost per square foot is misleading
- The change order trap: how small construction changes destroy your budget
- 7 things you need to check before the drywall goes up
- The model home lie: why what you see isn’t what you get

Before You Hand Over a Single Dollar to a Contractor, Read This First
Get Scott’s free guide in your inbox and go into your next builder or contractor conversation knowing what to ask.
